- Ezra Shaw/Getty
NetSuite’s largest institutional shareholder wants to block Oracle’s $9.3 billion acquisition of the company, arguing that the deal undervalues NetSuite and that Oracle CEO Larry Ellison’s relationship with NetSuite presents a major conflict of interest.
T. Rowe Price, one of the world’s largest mutual funds, has a more than 12.9% stake in NetSuite. The fund sent a letter to NetSuite on Wednesday announcing its opposition to the deal.
NetSuite disclosed the letter in a filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission. According to the letter, T. Rowe Price objects to the deal for five reasons:
NetSuite still holds value as a publicly traded, independent company. Oracle’s $9.3 billion offer is undervalued, considering that competitors like Workday are trading at an $18 billion market cap – higher than NetSuite’s $8.8 billion cap, but not unattainable in T. Rowe Price’s view. From T. Rowe Price’s perspective, Oracle’s offer doesn’t account for the “synergies” between the two companies. In other words, T. Rowe Price expects that Oracle is going to get a lot more value from adding NetSuite’s products to its stable than is reflected in the purchase price. There was no competing bid for NetSuite, which T. Rowe Price chalks up to Oracle founder Larry Ellison’s “unique relationship” with the company – Ellison is the largest single shareholder in NetSuite, with around 40% ownership, and he stands to make $3.5 billion from the sale. The concern is that NetSuite didn’t do its due diligence of seeking competing offers and instead went with Ellison’s by default. “In our view, the inherent conflicts of interest between NetSuite, the Ellison entities, and Oracle are daunting and may be impossible to manage,” T. Rowe Price wrote. So even if the price were to go up, the company would still have concerns.
“At this time none of the Portfolio Managers who own NetSuite stock within our firm intend to follow the board’s recommendation to tender our shares by September 15th,” T. Rowe Price wrote.
Shares of NetSuite and Oracle were essentially unchanged in midday trading on Wednesday. NetSuite reaffirmed to Business Insider that its board recommends accepting the deal. Oracle declined to comment.