Android phones everywhere are adopting the iPhone’s ‘notch’ design — and it’s causing them to miss a golden opportunity

source
Hollis Johnson

  • In the year since the iPhone X was released to the public, many phone makers have copied its signature design feature: the notch, or cutout, at the top center of the phone.
  • Notches weren’t “a thing” until the iPhone X came along.
  • Years from now, when Apple and others eventually eliminate the notches from their phones, we’ll wonder why competitors didn’t try to leapfrog the iPhone when they had the chance.

Last year, Apple unveiled a smartphone that looked completely different from all the other phones on the market.

source
Hollis Johnson

One year later, that design is everywhere.

source
Antonio Villas-Boas/Business Insider

Here’s the OnePlus 6.

source
Antonio Villas-Boas/Business Insider

Here’s the LG G7 ThinQ.

source
Antonio Villas-Boas/Business Insider

Here’s the Huawei P20 Pro.

source
Huawei

Here’s the Asus Zenfone 5.

source
Asus

Here’s the OnePlus 6T.

source
Antonio Villas-Boas/Business Insider

And here’s the Pixel 3 XL from Google.

source
Drew Angerer/Getty Images

See any similarities to Apple’s design?

source
Hollis Johnson/Business Insider

All of these smartphones have what people typically call a “notch,” or a cut-out at the top center of the phone.

source
Apple

Though Andy Rubin’s Essential Phone was actually the first to introduce this design a few months before the iPhone X last year, it wasn’t officially “a thing” until the iPhone X went on sale.

source
Antonio Villas-Boas/Business Insider

Google, in particular, is driving the adoption of notches among Android phones. Aside from the new Pixel 3 XL, Google’s latest version of Android supports notched smartphone designs, which makes it easier for other Android phone makers to build those kinds of phones. <i>Great.</i>

source
YouTube/MKBHD

For what it’s worth, copying Apple is nothing new — for better or worse.

source
Thomson Reuters

Apple’s smartphone designs have inspired the industry, and countless imitators, for years. Fingerprint sensors and virtual assistants weren’t “a thing” until Apple put those features in an iPhone. These days, you can’t find a smartphone without those features.

source
Business Insider/Steve Kovach

It happened again this year. In the 12 months since Apple unveiled the iPhone X, with its edge-to-edge display and “notch” at the top of the phone, numerous phone makers have introduced new smartphones that look just like the iPhone X — notch and all.

source
YouTube/SAMTIME

What’s particularly funny is that the notch, in many ways, represents an imperfection with current smartphones.

source
YouTube/sakitech

Apple specifically said the goal of the iPhone X was to make a smartphone that was “all screen” — and based on that definition, the iPhone X falls just short.

source
Hollis Johnson

The iPhone’s notch, though it powers a highly sophisticated security system, is the only blemish on an otherwise seamless display. It is edge-to-edge, technically, but not “all screen.”

source
Apple

In short, Android phone makers are squandering a golden opportunity to leapfrog Apple.

source
Reuters

What’s interesting is how few phone makers are even trying to solve this problem, as if the notch is not a clear design flaw. This phone from Sharp, for instance, has two notches!

source
Sharp

To give credit where it’s due, some companies are trying different things. Samsung chose not to go down the notch path at all with its Galaxy S and Note phones.

source
Antonio Villas-Boas/Business Insider

Other groups, like Chinese companies Oppo and Vivo, are also experimenting with ways to hide the selfie camera when it’s not in use.

source
YouTube/Unbox Therapy


Still, many companies, including Google, have simply accepted the notch without challenging it, or at least shrinking it. The notch on the Pixel 3 XL is massive, for instance.

source
YouTube/MKBHD

Perhaps some phone makers think it’s better to look like the competition than to try something different. But some day, probably soon, the iPhone will no longer have a notch, and other phone makers will then follow suit, eliminating the notches from their own phones. And we’ll look back on this time — the Notch Era — and shake our heads in wonderment. We’ll ask: Why did so many phone makers simply follow Apple, when they had a golden opportunity to jump ahead?

source
YouTube/Unbox Therapy