I tried a $189, 10-course meal at the eclectic San Francisco restaurant that makes ice cream from milk mixed with hot coals and morphs trout into ‘everything bagels’

Avery's Everything Trout features grilled trout topped with roe, or fish eggs, and the seasoning you would find on an Everything Bagel.

caption
Avery’s Everything Trout features grilled trout topped with roe, or fish eggs, and the seasoning you would find on an Everything Bagel.
source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

San Francisco has no shortage of restaurants, fine dining or otherwise, with menus boasting crazy high prices. Seven dollar bacon strips anyone?

The city’s newly-opened Avery restaurant isn’t any different in that sense. The prix-fixe East Asian-infused eatery takes reservations through Tock, the high-dollar restaurant equivalent of OpenTable that allows guests to reserve and pay for meals beforehand. No post-meal payment needed.

The restaurant is currently offering three menus: Cello Player, a smaller course plan for $89 a person, Avery’s Room, a reservation for six to eight people featuring a special menu from the kitchen, and the seafood-themed Bouquet of the Sea for $189 a pop.

I took a gander at the latter during a recent visit to Avery and concluded that when it comes to eating in this city, you get what you pay for – which in this case is 10 meticulously-crafted, delicious dishes for $189 a person.

Here’s what it was like.


In the city’s Fillmore neighborhood, Avery’s storefront is minimal and could be easy to miss if you aren’t looking for it.

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

The entry way features a black slatted wall. We were seated behind it, in a cozy booth.

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

My friend helped himself to one of the fleecy knit blankets available by the front door — they’re great for keeping guests warm in San Francisco’s infamous chilly night air.

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

We were seated on the restaurant’s downstairs level. Both floors are cozy and small, with only three other tables around us.

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

Through a hallway, the kitchen is in plain sight…

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

…and that’s where the magic happens.

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

Before Avery, chef Rodney Wages lent his culinary expertise to kitchens in other high-profile eateries, like Atelier Crenn and French Laundry. Needless to say he’s seasoned and, based on my interaction with him, a no-nonsense, straightforward chef, focused more on his food than on niceties. It made me respect the space more.


Our experience began with a toasted grain-y broth, filled maybe a quarter of the way in an artisan-looking bowl.

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

Our waiter, Max, told us to pick it right up and sip it. So we did.

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

Following the Grains was raw sea bream garnished with Japanese pickled turnip and cherry leaves, placed on a striking red platter. We ate them, and everything else in the meal, using the provided chopsticks.

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

Next up: the Everything Trout, one of the signature dishes.

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

These grilled fellas were adorned with roe, or fish eggs, and Everything seasoning, the same kind that you’d find on an Everything bagel. They were served on a textured plate that, in some strange way, complimented them even more. It started to become clear how much thought truly goes into every dish and its presentation.


Each dish was also spaced pretty well apart: a new one came every five to eight minutes I would say. Toasted potato cakes came next, overladen with strips of Spanish Iberico ham, and served with cultured cream. The cream mixed with the salty ham was fantastic.

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

A fan favorite, our server told us, was the Ableskiver, or Danish pancakes. They were piping hot and served on an arrangement of disconnected gold plates in varying sizes stacked on top of each other. The plate mesmerized me more than it probably should have.

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

The pancakes were stuffed with shrimp and avocado, all blended together into a hot creamy mix. I could see why it was a favored dish.

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

With the pancake balls also came grilled oysters with tomatoes, a dish I vowed to try and replicate though I doubt it will come out as good.

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

At this point in the meal, I was starting to fall behind in consuming my champagne and my Japanese “sake” rice wine.

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

My waiter brought me three different sakes throughout the night to be paired specially with certain dishes: the first was very bold, the second was a bit sweeter and the third, my favorite, had a strong cereal-like twinge to it. I loved and drank every glass, albeit slowly.


Next came the grilled cod perched atop a puffy cloud of Bearnaise Mousseline, a spinoff of Hollandaise sauce. I did a double take when our server said there was also chorizo in there somewhere…

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

…but sure enough, a deep spoonful of it confirmed as much. It was a pleasant unexpected taste.

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

My second favorite dish of the night was the Tortellini en Brodo, which came with foie gras and cultured butter.

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

The broth was heavenly and paired well with the grain-tasting sake.

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

The presentation of the Northern Coast dish was my favorite of all 10 courses.

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

All of its ingredients are sourced locally from California and together looked like something straight out of the ocean, in a good way. The bowl consisted of lamb carpaccio with morels, Abalone, and greens from the coastal area. The Abalone was my favorite out of the trio – it was perfectly tender.


One of Avery’s specialties is the Wagyu beef, meat sourced from the small Japanese island of Hokkaido. It was served with a surprising companion: BBQ sauce. The touch is a personal one from Wages, who’s a Kansas native. They paired perfectly together, with the beef literally melting in my mouth. It stunned me for a moment.

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

In between the last dinner course and our dessert course was a cheese tart with candied nuts. I have a rocky history with the delicacy, but these guys won me over. And, as my friend commented, it was a nice stepping stone between dinner and a sweet dessert…

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

…which was hands down my favorite part of the meal.

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

Small cakes served with Australian winter truffle and apricots came with ice cream made from grilled milk. Yes, grilled: burning coals are thrown into the milk, where they’re extinguished, which is then used to make the cream. A smoky aroma contrasted with each creamy spoonful. I’ve never had anything like it.


Overall, my visit at Avery was a special treat, one that, despite the bite-sized portions, left me feeling surprisingly full. It was a nice change from my usual $3 pizza slice for dinner. Though with meals costing at least $89 a person, eating at Avery will be reserved for special occasions for me.

source
Katie Canales/Business Insider

Avery is open Wednesday through Sunday from 5:30pm to 9:30pm. It’s located at 1552 Fillmore Street, San Francisco, Calif.