SpaceX tried to land a 16-story-tall rocket on the ground, but it plunged into the sea. These dramatic videos show what happened.

The booster, or first stage, of a SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket attempting to land.

caption
The booster, or first stage, of a SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket attempting to land.
source
SpaceX/Flickr (public domain)

  • Elon Musk‘s aerospace company, SpaceX, successfully launched a resupply ship for NASA to the International Space Station on Wednesday.
  • As a cost-saving bonus, SpaceX also tried to land the 16-story-tall booster of its Falcon 9 rocket on a ground pad at Cape Canaveral, Florida.
  • However, videos show the Falcon 9 rocket booster spinning wildly before taking a plunge into the ocean.
  • Musk blamed the anomaly on a faulty pump, but he said the booster is undamaged, being recovered, and can be reused for a future launch.

On Monday afternoon, SpaceX successfully launched a 4.6-ton Dragon cargo spacecraft full of supplies and experiments to astronauts in orbit.

“Dragon is on its way to the International Space Station. Capture by @Space_Station crew set for early Saturday morning,” SpaceX, the rocket company founded by Elon Musk, tweeted shortly after the Falcon 9 rocket launch.

As is now customary for SpaceX, the company also tried to land the biggest and most expensive part of its Falcon 9 rocket – the 16-story-tall booster, or first stage – back on Earth for refurbishment and future relaunch. (Reusing boosters could save SpaceX billions of dollars over the years and lower the cost of access to space, since orbital rockets typically crash into the ocean.)

But as the giant booster came screaming back to Florida with some fuel inside, a crucial system failed. The tense moment was captured during a live broadcast from SpaceX’s headquarters in Hawthorne, California.

The main parts of SpaceX's partly reusable Falcon 9 rocket system.

caption
The main parts of SpaceX’s partly reusable Falcon 9 rocket system.
source
SpaceX/Flickr; Business Insider

About one minute before the booster was scheduled to land in Cape Canaveral – while it was traveling at several hundred miles per hour – it began to teeter and spin around and around. The sight triggered a mixture of worried “oohs” and “aahs” from SpaceX employees who were watching, then the booster’s video feed cut out from the broadcast.

For a moment, it seemed as if the booster was flying out of control toward the ground. But cheers soon erupted from SpaceX employees. Musk later revealed that they were cheering the success of a backup plan: the booster “landed,” as gently as a towering object can, in the Atlantic Ocean.

“Falcon landed just out to sea. Appears to be undamaged & is transmitting data. Recovery ship dispatched,” Musk tweeted. He added that the booster will likely be reused for a future “internal” mission (which likely means for the launch of SpaceX’s next-generation internet satellites, called Starlink).

A few minutes later, Musk and others shared some dramatic and dizzying footage of the splashdown.

Watch SpaceX’s booster spin then splash into the sea

Musk shared the 45-second clip below, which picks up where the live broadcast cut out.

The footage shows the booster spinning while firing its rocket engines in an attempt to control the twirling and safely land – but with no ground in sight. It pops out its four landing legs, rockets toward the ocean’s surface, plunges in, bobs upward, and then tips over like a felled tree.

Musk blamed the failure on a hydraulic pump that pushes out one of the booster’s four titanium “grid fins.” These steerable, waffle-like devices help the rocket guide itself toward a landing site while returning to Earth, then stabilize the booster during landing.

As Monday’s launch of the CRS-16 mission showed, not deploying a grid fin in time can put the rocket into a tailspin, preventing it from steering toward a landing site.

“Some landing systems are not redundant, as landing is considered ground safety critical, but not mission critical. Given this event, we will likely add a backup,” Musk tweeted.

SpaceX wasn’t the only one to film the dramatic moment.

Chris Gebhardt, the assistant managing editor of NASASpaceFlight.com, was recording the booster’s return in Cape Canaveral with several others, and he helped capture the whole event on camera.

The clip below shows Gebhardt’s and others’ view from the ground. Several sonic booms from the booster’s supersonic descent to Earth can be heard before it splashes down just out of sight beyond a barrier island. (Turn on the sound to hear their commentary.)

Don’t out-of-control rockets blow themselves up?

Rockets that veer out of control typically self-destruct using what’s called an automated flight termination system, or AFTS. Such systems are put in place to protect people and equipment on the ground.

But in this case, self-destruct criteria weren’t met, and SpaceX got to perform a soft-ocean-landing maneuver that it has practiced before.

When SpaceX launched the CRS-16 resupply mission on Monday, it made sure the Falcon 9 rocket’s booster would hit the ocean if the landing system somehow failed. Only reigniting the booster’s engines for a precise landing burn would have pulled it off that trajectory and toward the ground pad.

A SpaceX Grasshopper rocket self-destructed in August 2014 after an engine sensor failure.

caption
A SpaceX Grasshopper rocket self-destructed in August 2014 after an engine sensor failure.
source
SpaceX/YouTube

If the booster had veered off-course more than two minutes before landing, Gebhardt said, then it would have exploded.

“A water-ditch landing is safer than an exploding rocket close to the ground,” he told Business Insider.

SpaceX is preparing to launch its first spacecraft to carry NASA astronauts, called Crew Dragon, in 2019. If SpaceX rockets misbehave, that could prompt the agency to perform a safety review and delay those experimental launches.

But in this case, nothing that’d be considered critical to NASA’s mission – only SpaceX’s convenience – seems to have gone wrong.