- Sun Wenguang, a prominent critic of the Chinese government, was forced off the air during a live phone interview earlier this week.
- He had been arguing that Xi Jinping should focus less on multi-billion-dollar programs abroad, and more on alleviating poverty at home.
- Part-way through the discussion, Sun described a group of police officers entering his home.
- He said: “Let me tell you, it’s illegal for you to come to my home… I have my freedom of speech!”
- Then the line went dead. Now there is no information on where he is.
A prominent critic of the Chinese government was forced off-air by state police while he was criticizing Xi Jinping in a live phone interview.
Sun Wenguang, a retired economics professor in his 80s, had on Wednesday evening been criticizing the country’s expenditure on foreign aid, loans, and investment.
He said that Xi’s China had its priorities wrong, and should be spending the money on domestic programs instead.
The professor, who lives in Jinan, was speaking to Voice of America Mandarin, a Chinese-language outlet funded by the US government.
In a live phone interview, he said that Xi should spend more money alleviating poverty in China, rather than “throw money at other countries,” particularly those in Africa.
- REUTERS/Christopher Herwi
Then, in the middle of his sentence, Sun suddenly said: “Here they come again, the police are here to interrupt again,” before counting the number of people who had entered his home. He counted to about eight of them.
“What, did I say something wrong? Listen to what I say, is it wrong?” Sun appears to ask the intruders, before appearing to continue his interview: “People are poor. Let’s not throw our money in Africa. The seven, eight of you here, listen up, throwing money like this is of no good to our country and society.”
“Let me tell you, it’s illegal for you to come to my home,” he added. “I have my freedom of speech!”
Then, the line went dead.
This is the audio (in Chinese):
Journalists from VOA have since been unable to contact him, and it’s not clear where he went.
Calls made to China’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs by VOA and CNN reporters went unanswered. Shandong University, where Sun used to teach, and Jinan police also refused to comment when VOA contacted them.
Marco Rubio, one of the US government’s largest critics of China, tweeted in response to the story: “Every time you hear overblown rhetoric about how we are on the verge of ‘tyranny’ or ‘authoritarianism’ in America remember what real tyranny& authoritarianism looks like.”
- Jason Lee/Reuters
Not his first run-in with police
Sun is a longtime critic of the Chinese government, and has been speaking out since long before Xi took power. Here’s his record, according to Human Rights Watch:
- Somewhere between 1966 and 1976 (Mao Zedong’s Cultural Revolution): Detained twice for a total of 2.5 years for what was described as “counterrevolutionary speech.”
- 1974 (separately): Detained for 3.5 years.
- 1978: Sentenced to seven years in a forced labor camp on charges of criticizing Mao, only to be restored into public and political life in 1982.
- 2009: Attacked by unidentified assailants while on his way to a memorial for Zhao Ziyang, the former Chinese prime minister who was dismissed after supporting anti-government protesters at Tiananmen Square.
- 2009-2012: Placed under house arrest during various local election campaigns.
He has criticized China’s restrictions on press freedom, corruption, and treatment of activist Liu Xiaobo, a Nobel peace prize laureate who spent nine years in Chinese captivity.
He has also published books outside of mainland China, including “Calling for Freedom” and “A Country in a Century of Trouble: From Mao Zedong to Jiang Zemin,” which could be purchased in Hong Kong.
“Throw-money diplomacy” – what Sun was talking about before he got cut off
Sun on Wednesday was criticizing what he described as Xi’s “throw-money diplomacy” – the idea that Beijing is investing in foreign countries to further its own political and economic aims.
Under Xi’s leadership, Beijing has ramped up both foreign direct investments in countries, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa, as well as encouraged economic partnerships with more than 70 countries across Asia, Europe, and Africa, as part of its “Belt and Road’ initiative.
Xi recently visited four countries around sub-Saharan Africa to cement Beijing’s role as the continent’s largest economic ally. China is Africa’s largest trading partner and source of foreign direct investment.
- Jason Lee/Getty
One prominent casualty of China’s using investment to further its political aims is Taiwan, which identifies as an independent nation but which Beijing insists is a Chinese territory.
The small island nation was recently left with 19 allies in the world and blamed it on China’s using “dollar diplomacy” to pressure economic allies to cut ties with Taiwan.
Before he was forced off-air, Sun said that Xi “wants to make nice with African countries, and that’s not what we are against.
“But there are so many other things for him to take into account. China has got a huge population, and there are still so many people living in destitution. …
“If you don’t actually have the scale of capability to match up with the scale of things you are trying to do, just don’t do it. …
“[If] you still choose to throw money at other countries, domestic backlash is almost guaranteed.”