New York City’s Financial District has a gory, haunted past

caption
Trinity Church’s graveyard, at Wall St.
source
Sarah Jacobs

New York’s Financial District is the economic center of the entire US – but it’s also one of the city’s most historically gruesome, gory, and bloody neighborhoods.

Although its cobblestone streets might seem innocent, the next time you’re in the area just remind yourself: More than 120,000 bodies have been buried on top of each other in the famous Trinity Church cemetery. City Hall Park is said to still be haunted to this day from all of the public hangings and lynchings that happened there in the 1800s.

Boroughs of the Dead, founded by Andrea Janes in 2013, leads unconventional walking tours that explore New York’s dark, strange, and downright chilling nooks and crannies.

Just in time for Halloween, the company is running on double time, with multiple tours happening throughout Manhattan, Brooklyn, and Queens. I chose to take a tour through the Financial District with Janes herself.

Although Janes made it clear that she doesn’t claim to be “clairvoyant by any means” there were several stops on the “Forgotten Dark Histories of Lower Manhattan” tour that she promised were “nauseating, intense, and overwhelming” due to their history. Below, a few highlights from our two-hour tour.


caption
The National Museum of the American Indian
source
Sarah Jacobs

We began our tour outside the National Museum of the American Indian, where Janes shares the gruesome story of the massacre of the Algonquian Indian tribe. Led by Willem Kieft, the director general of New Amsterdam in the 1640s, the bloody battle began at the very site where the museum can be found today.

When the tribe refused to pay taxes that Kieft had attempted to enforce, Kieft was more than a little upset. He decided to kill every man, woman, and child of the Algonquin tribe, focusing on the women and children. Fort Amsterdam was decorated with the heads of the slain American Indians.

To this day, there are tales of the ghost of a Native American woman wandering through the Bowling Green area.


caption
Fraunces Tavern on Pearl Street
source
Sarah Jacobs

If you work near the intersection of Pearl and Broad Streets, you might frequent Fraunces Tavern for happy hour. The tavern is well known for its rich history: George Washington and the Sons of Liberty would come to the Tavern before the start of the Revolutionary War, and Washington held his extremely emotional farewell banquet on the third floor after the War was over. There was also reportedly a murder, and a suicide occurred on the premises in 1712.

Many unverified reports of “paranormal instances” have been said to occur in this tavern. People have reported feeling a slight pressure on their back as though they’re being pushed, doors have mysteriously slammed shut, keys have been seen gently swaying as though someone – or something – had brushed their finger along them. Janes also told the group a bartender’s tale of both a night porter and a bouncer who once quit mid-shift for undisclosed reasons.


caption
Federal Hall on Wall Street
source
Sarah Jacobs

As Janes led us to Federal Hall on Wall Street, she told the group, “If you are a tour guide who loves 18th-century history, you will think of Wall Street not as a place where money was traded, but where human flesh was bought and sold.”

In 1736, at the foot of Wall Street closer to the water, she explained, you would find a slave market. In fact, after Charleston, North Carolina, New York was the single largest slave-owning port city in the British colonies.

Back in 1741, Federal Hall was known as British City Hall. On the top floor was a jail, and in the basement, a dungeon. During the slave rebellion of that year, more than 100 men were captured and imprisoned in the dungeon and kept for the entire summer. Many of the prisoners were killed without warrant.


caption
The south side of Trinity Church at Wall Street
source
Sarah Jacobs

The Trinity Church we know today is the third iteration of the church and was built in the 1830s, but its graveyard has been around since the 1690s. That’s plenty of time for lots and lots of dead bodies to be buried. So many, in fact, that in 1822 the sexton of the Church found himself desperate to find new spots for the newly deceased.

According to Janes, the sexton would “go around with a spade, testing the earth and see where it was soft, where the coffins and corpses had become decrepit enough that you could dig right into them, and take the bones into the charnel house, and bury somebody new.”

Today, there are over 120,000 shallowly buried bodies in the Church’s graveyard.


caption
Inside City Hall grounds, facing Chambers Street
source
Sarah Jacobs

In the late 1770s, New York City was a very different place, and Janes painted a fantastic, chilling image during our last stop just inside the City Hall Park grounds, near Broadway and Chambers Street.

At the time of the Revolutionary War, City Hall did not yet exist. In its place were two jailhouses, filled to the brim with American soldiers who had been caught by the British. Prisoners were either starved or served moldy bread made with flour that was sometimes laced with arsenic. Their close quarters caused disease, such as smallpox, to spread like wildfire. Sometimes, if a “particularly sadistic officer” was watching during the night shifts, Janes explained, a couple dozen prisoners would be rounded up, bound and gagged, and hung without due process or trial – right on Chambers Street.

The plot of land pictured above, behind the lamp post, was the burial site for these murders. Skulls and human remains are sometimes discovered there when ground is broken for new buildings in the area.

As the night came to an end, our fellow tour members left with a new perspective of the neighborhood – hurrying to the train a little faster than when we first arrived.